Homelessness Minister Slams Anti-Rough Sleeper Noise Devices in East Perth
Western Australia's Homelessness Minister, Matthew Swinbourn, has criticized high-pitched noise devices installed to deter rough sleepers at an East Perth underpass. The Minister emphasized that the WA government did not endorse the installation, stressing the need to treat people experiencing homelessness with dignity.
Key Developments
- The devices, which emit a constant high-pitched ringing, were installed at the Lord Street underpass by the Public Transport Authority (PTA). This action followed a request from the City of Perth.
- Minister Swinbourn stated the WA government did not endorse the installation, advocating for dignified treatment of people experiencing homelessness and the exploration of alternative approaches.
- A PTA spokesperson confirmed that the device has been switched off. The authority indicated it would collaborate with the City of Perth to identify a more suitable solution for the area.
- The City of Perth spokesperson mentioned the devices were installed due to reports of antisocial and criminal behavior. They clarified that the devices were not intended to specifically target people experiencing homelessness, with the city's focus remaining on improving safety and amenity.
Background
The Lord Street underpass is strategically situated near several homelessness support organizations. It has previously been utilized as a shelter by individuals experiencing homelessness.
Community and Official Responses
Housing campaigner Jesse Noakes, from The Last Place on Earth, described the sound emitted by the devices as "visceral" and "sickening," questioning its appropriateness as a response to homelessness. Cyclists and commuters also reportedly complained about the incessant noise.
Les, a 37-year-old Perth man who previously slept in the area, observed that the devices had deterred some individuals from setting up tents. However, he added a critical caveat: "they wouldn't stop those in urgent need of sleep."
Housing Minister and Perth MLA John Carey, while unaware of the device installation prior to its deployment, acknowledged existing concerns about anti-social behavior and reported assaults in the underpass area. He unequivocally stated that the government does not endorse the use of high-pitched sound devices. Minister Carey suggested that improved community safety could be more effectively achieved through better design or enhanced lighting instead.