Back
Sports

NCAA Tournaments Progress to Final Stages, Coaching Carousel Anticipated

View source

The college basketball season is approaching its climax, with the men's NCAA Tournament advancing through the Sweet Sixteen and Elite Eight rounds to determine the Final Four contenders. Simultaneously, the women's tournament has also seen teams secure their spots in the Final Four. Amidst this intense on-court action, discussions surrounding the future of numerous coaching positions have intensified, with many high-major programs expected to undergo changes. Concurrently, pressing issues such as revenue sharing, mid-major scheduling challenges, and the profound impact of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) policies remain prominent topics within the sport.

NCAA Men's Tournament Overview

Pre-Tournament Discussions and Early Round Insights

Before the tournament commenced, several teams were singled out for their potential for early exits or as "bracket busters." Nebraska, Alabama, Virginia, UConn, and Michigan were among the top seeds highlighted for potential challenges due to factors like inconsistent performance, defensive rankings, or difficult matchups.

Miami (Ohio), following an impressive 31-0 regular season, faced uncertainty regarding an NCAA Tournament bid after a first-round loss in its conference tournament. This sparked considerable debate about the true weight of regular-season records versus strength of schedule. The discussion surrounding strength of schedule was particularly prominent, with coaches from teams like High Point advocating for high-major programs to play mid-majors earlier in the season.

The impact of NIL on March Madness also garnered significant attention, with views ranging from its benefit to players to concerns that it widens the talent gap, potentially reducing "Cinderella" runs.

First Round (Round of 64) Highlights

The Round of 64 delivered several notable outcomes:

  • Nebraska secured its first-ever NCAA Tournament victory with a dominant 76-47 win against 14th-seeded Troy, held in Oklahoma City.
  • Duke, a No. 1 seed, overcame a significant second-half deficit against 16th-seeded Siena. Coach Jon Scheyer implemented a press defense followed by a 3-2 zone to slow Siena's offense and secure the win.
  • Sixth-seeded North Carolina was eliminated after blowing a 19-point lead in an overtime loss to VCU, marking the largest blown lead in a Round of 64 game. VCU's bench played a crucial role in their impressive comeback.
  • Kentucky advanced to overtime against Santa Clara, with Otega Oweh banking in a 32-foot 3-pointer to tie the score at 73-73 as time expired. Oweh finished with 35 points in Kentucky's eventual overtime victory.
  • Alabama, a No. 4 seed, defeated Hofstra 90-70, with Labaron Philon Jr. scoring 29 points. Alabama played without its second-leading scorer, Aden Holloway, who was absent due to an arrest on felony drug charges.
  • Iowa State secured a 108-74 victory over Tennessee State, despite their leading scorer, Joshua Jefferson, sustaining an ankle injury early in the game.
  • Texas Tech defeated Akron 91-71, maintaining a lead throughout the game.
  • Virginia achieved its first NCAA Tournament win since 2019, overcoming an early deficit against Wright State.
  • Arkansas defeated High Point, with freshman Darius Acuff Jr. scoring an impressive 36 points.
  • TCU recorded its first NCAA Tournament victory since 2023, overcoming a 15-point halftime lead held by Ohio State.

Second Round (Round of 32) Highlights

The Round of 32 saw more thrilling action:

  • Michigan defeated Saint Louis 95-72, displaying strong defensive prowess with significant length from players like 7-foot-3 center Aday Mara, who contributed four blocks.
  • Nebraska eliminated Vanderbilt, winning a close game that saw Vanderbilt's Tyler Tanner score 27 points.
  • Illinois defeated VCU 76-55, with a deep lineup contributing to their offensive output.
  • Iowa defeated defending national champion Florida in a physically contested game, controlling the pace and securing a victory under first-year coach Ben McCollum.
  • Kansas was eliminated by St. John's, with Dylan Darling scoring a buzzer-beating layup. This marked Kansas's fourth consecutive season not advancing past the first weekend of the NCAA Tournament.

Following the first weekend, the Sweet Sixteen was primarily composed of top-seeded teams, with No. 11 Texas, No. 9 Iowa, No. 6 Tennessee, and No. 5 St. John's being the lowest seeds to advance. For the second consecutive year, no teams from non-power conferences reached the Sweet Sixteen.

Elite Eight Matchups and Results

The Elite Eight featured several highly anticipated matchups, with the first Final Four contender already decided:

South Region Final: No. 3 Illinois vs. No. 9 Iowa
  • Illinois defeated Iowa 71-59, securing its first Final Four appearance since 2005. Illinois's Andrej Stojakovic contributed 17 points, and freshman guard Keaton Wagler led the team with 25 points. Iowa, under coach Ben McCollum, had previously defeated defending national champion Florida and fourth-seeded Nebraska to reach this stage.
West Region Final: No. 1 Arizona vs. No. 2 Purdue
  • Arizona entered with 12 consecutive wins, and Purdue was undefeated since the regular season. Purdue advanced to the Elite Eight with a last-second tip-in against 11th-seeded Texas. Arizona defeated No. 4 Arkansas 109-88 in the Sweet Sixteen.
Midwest Region Final: No. 1 Michigan vs. No. 6 Tennessee
  • Michigan, coached by Dusty May, had won its three tournament games by a combined 57 points, with Yaxel Lendeborg achieving 23 points, 12 rebounds, and seven assists against Alabama. Tennessee, under Rick Barnes, reached its third consecutive Elite Eight and demonstrated strong rebounding, outrebounding Iowa State 42-18 in the Sweet Sixteen.
East Region Final: No. 1 Duke vs. No. 2 UConn
  • Duke, led by coach Jon Scheyer, defeated St. John's 80-75 in the Sweet Sixteen, with Cameron Boozer contributing 22 points and 10 rebounds. UConn, coached by Dan Hurley, advanced with wins against Furman, UCLA, and Michigan State, recovering from a loss in the Big East tournament final.

The men's Final Four is scheduled for April 4 at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis, with the national championship game two days later.

NCAA Women's Tournament Progress

The women's NCAA Tournament has also progressed significantly, with the Sweet Sixteen concluding and two teams already securing berths in the Final Four.

  • Top-seeded UConn, boasting an undefeated 38-0 record and a remarkable 54-game winning streak, defeated sixth-seeded Notre Dame 70-52 in Fort Worth. This victory marked their 17th Final Four appearance in 18 seasons.
  • Top-seeded UCLA advanced to its second consecutive Final Four, extending its winning streak to 29 games. The Bruins overcame a double-digit deficit against No. 3 Duke, winning 70-58. This loss marked Duke's sixth consecutive Elite Eight defeat.

College Basketball Coaching Landscape

The conclusion of the regular season has initiated an active coaching carousel, with sources indicating that over ten high-major positions are expected to become available. Kansas State has already made a coaching change, parting ways with Jerome Tang.

Coaches Under Review (Hot Seat)

Several coaches faced intensified scrutiny based on team performance and contract situations:

  • Adrian Autry (Syracuse): Team had not reached the NCAA Tournament in three seasons.
  • Jeff Capel (Pittsburgh): Team was 10-17, with only one NCAA Tournament appearance in eight years.
  • Kim English (Providence): Team experienced multiple overtime and home conference losses despite significant NIL investments.
  • Earl Grant (Boston College): Team projected for the highest loss total of his tenure, compounded by an eight-game losing streak.
  • Bobby Hurley (Arizona State): In the final year of his contract, the team was 14-13 and not contending for the NCAA Tournament.
  • Matt McMahon (LSU): Held a 16-52 record in SEC games over four years.
  • Porter Moser (Oklahoma): Had not achieved a .500 or better record in SEC play over five years.
  • Damon Stoudamire (Georgia Tech): Team had not won since January 17th.

Situations to Monitor

  • Jake Diebler (Ohio State): Team was hovering on the NCAA Tournament bubble.
  • Steve Forbes (Wake Forest): Program showed improvement but was likely to miss the NCAA Tournament for a sixth consecutive season.
  • Penny Hardaway (Memphis): Team was 12-15, performing below expectations given available resources.
  • Thad Matta (Butler): Team was 15-13 after a six-game losing streak, which removed them from NCAA Tournament consideration.

Likely Safe, For Now

  • Ed Cooley (Georgetown)
  • Hubert Davis (North Carolina)
  • Lamont Paris (South Carolina)
  • Steve Pikiell (Rutgers)
  • Micah Shrewsberry (Notre Dame)
    These coaches were identified as having job security due to factors such as long-term contracts, recent extensions, or acknowledged challenges like injuries or recruiting limitations.

Retirement Watch

Several veteran coaches were noted for potential retirement considerations, including:

  • Dana Altman (Oregon)
  • Rick Barnes (Tennessee)
  • Tad Boyle (Colorado)
  • Mark Few (Gonzaga)
  • Anthony Grant (Dayton)
  • Tom Izzo (Michigan State)
  • Greg McDermott (Creighton)
  • Bill Self (Kansas)

Open Positions

Already open coaching positions included:

  • Kansas State
  • San Diego
  • Air Force
  • Tarleton State
  • Cal State Bakersfield
  • North Florida

Top Head Coach Candidates

A group of head coaches from successful programs were identified as leading candidates for high-major vacancies:

  • Josh Schertz (Saint Louis): Known for tactical abilities at Saint Louis, Indiana State, and Lincoln Memorial.
  • Jerrod Calhoun (Utah State): Developed Youngstown State and led Utah State to consistent NCAA Tournament contention, recognized for offensive strategies and transfer portal use.
  • Casey Alexander (Belmont): Achieved over 20 wins in ten consecutive seasons, valued for talent evaluation and offensive system.
  • Bryan Hodgson (South Florida): Formerly a top recruiter at Alabama, quickly improved Arkansas State and led South Florida to the top of the AAC in his first year.
  • Joe Gallo (Merrimack): Guided Merrimack through a successful transition from Division II, securing NEC and MAAC regular-season titles with a distinctive zone defense.
  • Eric Olen (New Mexico): Transitioned from UC San Diego to New Mexico, quickly positioning the Lobos for an NCAA Tournament bid in his first year after a team rebuild.
  • Travis Steele (Miami, Ohio): Led Miami (Ohio) to a 29-0 record, a significant turnaround for the program.
  • Takayo Siddle (UNC Wilmington): Established UNC Wilmington as a consistent winner, achieving 27 wins last year and sharing the CAA regular-season title with another 25-win campaign.
  • Tony Skinn (George Mason): Led George Mason to three consecutive 20-win seasons.
  • James Jones (Yale): Built a successful program at Yale, leading the Bulldogs to consecutive NCAA Tournaments and strong KenPom rankings despite Ivy League limitations.

Assistant Coaches to Watch

Several assistant coaches were also highlighted as potential candidates for head coaching roles:

  • Luke Murray (UConn)
  • JR Blount (Iowa State)
  • Carlin Hartman (Florida)
  • Mike Boynton (Michigan)
  • Emanuel Dildy (Duke)
  • Jeff Linder (Texas Tech)
  • Justin Gainey (Tennessee)

Conference Developments and Financial Impact

Big East Revenue Sharing

Discussions in 2024 and 2025 revolved around the potential for the basketball-focused Big East Conference to gain a competitive advantage from the House v. NCAA settlement's revenue sharing. The premise suggested that Big East schools would primarily invest their $20.5 million revenue share in men's basketball, unlike football-centric schools.

However, in the initial year of the Revenue Share Era (2026), the Big East Conference was projected to be a three-bid NCAA tournament league, among its lowest in 46 years.

Factors contributing to this outcome included initial competitive disadvantage concerns being overstated, schools lacking substantial non-football revenue for large allocations, the $20.5 million not being a strict cap, major conferences maintaining competitive NIL strategies, and some Big East schools not seeing expected returns or being slow to adapt their strategies.

Mid-Major Challenges and Tournament Expansion

Mid-major teams frequently encountered difficulties in scheduling high-quality non-conference opponents, which adversely impacted their NET rankings. NCAA Vice President for Basketball Dan Gavitt acknowledged these struggles. There were ongoing discussions about expanding the NCAA Tournament field, but some coaches expressed skepticism, believing that most additional bids would likely go to Power 5 teams rather than significantly increasing mid-major representation.

Notable Team Achievements

Nova Southeastern's Home Winning Streak

Division II Nova Southeastern in Fort Lauderdale attempted to win its 100th consecutive home game, a streak believed to be the second-longest home winning streak in men's college basketball history, trailing only Kentucky's 129 straight wins from 1943 to 1955.

The Sharks, who are defending D-II national champions, last experienced a home loss on February 15, 2020.