Review: Netflix's 'Heartbreak High' Remake

A recent review discusses the Netflix remake of "Heartbreak High," noting its sprightly energy and fresh-faced cast, but contrasting its tone with the 1990s original.

The original "Heartbreak High" was characterized by its realism, gritty aesthetic, and a diverse cast. In comparison, the new series is described as having a polished appearance, a jokey tone, and pat writing.

Contemporary Themes, Different Approach

The new series addresses contemporary youth issues such as abortion, mental health, gender politics, bullying, and racial tensions. However, it is perceived as lacking the directness of its predecessor.

The Final Season's Plotlines

The third and final season of the remake focuses on the characters' last year of high school, starting with a "muck-up day" prank.

A central mystery throughout the eight episodes involves a theme park ride incident that left an employee in a coma, with the narrative described as a "pseudo-whodunnit."

The season also explores relationship dynamics between Amerie (Ayesha Madon) and Malakai (Thomas Weatherall), and romantic tensions between Spider (Bryn Chapman Parish) and Missy (Sherry-Lee Watson). Character aspirations are highlighted through Darren's (James Majoos) acting ambitions and Harper's (Asher Yasbincek) goal to be a visual artist.

Creative Intent vs. Execution

Creator Hannah Carroll Chapman may have intended the show to be an Australian equivalent of "Sex Education." However, the direction by Jessie Oldfield, Adam Murfet, Tig Terera, and Nina Buxton is described as colorful but contrived. The series is seen as rarely achieving strong emotional impact.

Emotional moments, such as an opening montage with Amerie reflecting on high school, are noted as being designed to generate feeling rather than earning it.

The series' conclusion is characterized as favoring sentiment over subtlety.