California Ballot Initiative Seeks to Repeal Top-Two Primary System

A ballot initiative has been filed to repeal California's top-two primary system, potentially restoring traditional party primaries. Political consultant Steve Maviglio submitted the application on Friday.

The initiative seeks to replace the current top-two primary—where the two highest vote-getters advance regardless of party—with a system where the top candidate from each party proceeds to the general election.

Key Details

• The measure would appear on the 2028 ballot and take effect in 2030.
• The current system has been in place since Proposition 14 passed in 2010.

Background

Proposition 14 was supported by then-Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger and opposed by major political parties. Its goals included reducing partisan gridlock and encouraging candidates to appeal to a broader electorate.

Notable races under the system include the 2012 congressional contest between Democratic Reps. Brad Sherman and Howard Berman, a high-profile example of same-party candidates facing off in a general election.

Statements

Maviglio cited concerns that the current system could result in two Republican candidates for governor, despite Democratic voters outnumbering Republicans.

California Secretary of State Shirley Weber stated she voted against Proposition 14 and questioned whether it achieved its objectives.

The initiative's website includes criticisms from both Democratic Party Chair Rusty Hicks and former California Republican Party Chair Ron Nehring, highlighting bipartisan unease with the current system.

Additional Context

• The initiative was first reported by The New York Times.
• Discussions about changing Proposition 14 have been ongoing in Sacramento for months, indicating growing legislative interest in revisiting California's primary election structure.