Windsor Pub’s Tree Dispute Delays Multimillion-Dollar Renovation
"This is a five-month process to remove one tree," said owner Liam Ganley.
Melbourne, Australia – A bitter five-month dispute between the owner of the historic Windsor Castle Hotel and Stonnington Council over a single tree has stalled a major redevelopment, leaving the pub closed and costing thousands in lost revenue.
The Core Conflict
The issue centers on a Bhutan Cypress tree located on the edge of the pub's beer garden. Pub owner Liam Ganley sought to remove the tree to make way for a three-metre-tall double-brick wall, designed to reduce noise for neighbors as part of a multimillion-dollar renovation.
The council granted a planning permit in December 2025 but specifically prohibited removal of the tree, directing Ganley to apply for a separate tree-works permit. That permit was denied in January 2026, with the council citing the “climate emergency” and stating that retaining large trees is “critically important.”
Appeal and Reversal
Ganley appealed the denial, but was rejected in April 2026. However, in a late Friday decision on June 12, 2026, the council granted provisional approval for the tree’s removal, subject to conditions including the planting of a replacement tree.
Financial Toll
Ganley expressed deep frustration with the timeline. The pub has been closed for two weeks, with Ganley reporting a loss of approximately $10,000 per week during the closure.
"The redevelopment remains in limbo," he said.
Council’s Response
Stonnington Council CEO Dale Dickson defended the process, stating that Ganley’s company did not provide sufficient evidence for the tree removal in a timely manner. Once the evidence was provided, Dickson noted, the permit was approved within six business days.
Looking Ahead
Ganley Group purchased the pub in 2024 after it entered voluntary administration. With the tree issue now resolved, Ganley hopes to reopen in March or April 2027, after missing the crucial summer season.