Australia’s Publishing Industry: A Crisis of Quality and Care
An article examines concerns within Australia's publishing industry regarding rushed production schedules, declining editorial quality, and the difficulties authors face in promoting their work. It draws on interviews with authors, publishers, and booksellers.
Key Complaints from Authors
"A main character's name changed mid-book in the first print run."
- Rebecca (pseudonym): Her debut nonfiction had a pivotal chapter removed without her knowledge. Cover art featured an animal from a different country. Copy editors queried references to hunting for possibly offending vegetarians. A main character's name changed mid-book in the first print run.
"He described his press's own publicity copy as 'written by AI'."
-
Lee (pseudonym): His independent press publisher sent out publicity copy he described as "written by AI" that mischaracterized his novel for a children's audience, despite his veto. The early version defined the book's reception.
-
Jennifer Mills (author, chair of Australian Society of Authors): She spends 3–6 years writing a book. She states writers are paid for the product, not labor, and face shorter publishing and publicity schedules.
Industry Context: Pressures and Trends
- NielsenIQ BookData: Approximately 9,400 Australian print books were scheduled for publication in 2024, down 7% from the 10-year average. This excludes self-published ebooks.
- Production pressures: Rising printing costs, flat book prices, loss of independent publishers and bookshops, competition from Amazon and discount stores. Industry figures, including Richard Flanagan, have called for government price-fixing measures.
- Quality concerns: Authors, editors, and prize judges report shoddy copy editing, errors, and lack of revision. Alice Grundy (Australia Institute Press) notes a "collapsed timeframe" for production.
- Short shelf life: Research by Van Loon, Coate, and Weber indicates new titles typically get three months on shelves before being returned or remaindered. Nationally significant books like "No Friend But the Mountains" and "Dark Emu" took longer to gain traction.
- Author income: Creative Australia (2022) found average author earnings from writing at $18,200 per year.
Alternative Approaches: Slowing Down
- Emily Riches (Aniko Press): Spent three years on one book, with no other titles lined up. Prioritizes quality and reader care over speed.
- Margot Lloyd and Emily Hart (Pink Shorts Press): Republish older works and curate a short list, relying on instinct rather than data.
Notable Fast-Track Example
"Authors spent more time touring than writing."
"The Mushroom Tapes" was announced in July 2024 (after Erin Patterson's murder conviction) and published by November 2024. Authors spent more time touring than writing.