New Hampshire Episcopal Bishop Rob Hirschfeld advised clergy to prepare their wills, stating that a "new era of martyrdom" may require them to "stand between the powers of this world and the most vulnerable." His comments followed a vigil in Concord, N.H., for Renee Macklin Good, who was fatally shot by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent in Minneapolis.
Bishop's Statement and Reactions
Bishop Hirschfeld's remarks quickly gained national attention, eliciting varied responses from clergy.
- Support: Reverend Jason Wells of St. Matthews Episcopal Church and Reverend Betsy Hess of St. Barnabas Episcopal Church expressed relief and validation, viewing the statement as an acknowledgment of the anxieties felt by faith leaders involved in protests against ICE. Hess noted a need for clergy to "move beyond 'I won't do anything that has any risk whatsoever.'"
- Criticism: Reverend Tom Gartin of Faith Episcopal Church in California described the bishop's message as "inflammatory" and a "war cry," disagreeing with the concept of physical resistance and emphasizing the Episcopal tenet of Via Media (finding a middle path) and the importance of peacemaking. Gartin also expressed concern for his family and congregation should he become a martyr.
Clarification and Broader Context
Hirschfeld stated he was surprised by the stir his comments created and clarified his intent, saying he did not mean to incite violence. He explained his message as encouraging clergy to "live your life without fear of death" and "be ready, have your affairs in order, have your soul ready, in case you find yourself in trouble." He cited historical figures like Jonathan Daniels, a New Hampshire native and seminary student martyred in 1965 while aiding civil rights, as embodying the Episcopal tradition of activism.
Hirschfeld acknowledged the increasing dangers in public demonstrations, noting an open-carry state environment in New Hampshire, but asserted that this should not prevent participation.
Official Responses
- White House: Spokeswoman Abigail Jackson stated that interfering with federal law enforcement is a crime and will be prosecuted, reiterating the administration's stance that the ICE agent in Minneapolis acted in self-defense.
- DHS: Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin called Hirschfeld's comments "absurd" and suggested he should support ICE agents, who are reportedly under increasing attack.
Bishop Hirschfeld expressed compassion for ICE agents, stating it is a "Christian responsibility to extend love even to our enemies" and that he prays for "everyone's conversion of heart."