Back
Sports

AFL Premiership Season: Pre-Season to Round 4 Overview of Results, Team Developments, and League Issues

Generated on: Last updated: 194 sources
View source

The initial phase of the 2026 AFL Premiership Season, spanning from pre-season activities to the conclusion of Round 4, has featured significant match outcomes, player movements, injury challenges, and ongoing league-wide discussions. Key events included the introduction of new rules impacting ruck play, notable comebacks and dominant victories, and increasing scrutiny on team performance and coaching tenures. Player conduct incidents led to tribunal action, while competitive balance and player welfare remained points of focus across the league.

Pre-Season Overview (February 2026)

Match Simulations and Results

Unofficial match simulations were conducted across the league, providing early insights into team preparations:

  • Hawthorn defeated Geelong by 17 points (111-94) at Kennedy Community Centre. Geelong's Jay Polkinghorne (3 goals) and Shannon Neale (4 goals) performed, while Hawthorn's Josh Ward showed strong midfield presence. Hawthorn's forwards, however, were criticized for a 20.8% goal conversion rate.
  • Carlton defeated Brisbane by 15 points (103-88). Carlton's Talor Byrne kicked three final-quarter goals, and Jagga Smith impressed in midfield. Ben Ainsworth (4 goals) and Will Hayward (2 goals) also contributed for Carlton.
  • Sydney defeated the Western Bulldogs (99-66) at Mission Whitten Oval. Sydney recruit Charlie Curnow kicked four goals, and Malcolm Rosas added two.
  • St Kilda defeated Gold Coast by 71 points (107-36) at People First Stadium. St Kilda's Max Hall scored four goals, and Sam Flanders performed well in a midfield role.
  • Essendon defeated Richmond by 50 points (118-68). Essendon's Darcy Parish was influential with two goals, and Nate Caddy kicked four goals.
  • Greater Western Sydney defeated Collingwood by 35 points (110-75) at La Trobe University Sports Park. GWS recruit Clayton Oliver was prominent in midfield, while Kieren Briggs (4 goals) and Nick Madden (3 goals) were effective ruck-forwards.
  • Melbourne defeated North Melbourne by 80 points (129-49) at Casey Fields. Melbourne's Kysaiah Pickett scored five goals, and Jack Steele was strong in midfield.
  • Adelaide defeated Port Adelaide by 19 points (94-75) at Alberton Oval. Adelaide's Riley Thilthorpe kicked five goals, and Jordan Dawson was effective as a resting forward.
  • Fremantle defeated West Coast by 28 points (81-53) at Victor George Kailis Oval. Fremantle's Jye Amiss (4 goals) and Pat Voss (3 goals) led the attack. West Coast's Willem Duursma scored the opening goal.

Rule Changes and Impact

The removal of the sub rule now allows teams five players on the bench, potentially encouraging the use of two tall players. New rules also prohibit rucks from crossing the center line before engaging an opposition ruck, aiming to emphasize jumping rucks. Several teams, including Hawthorn, Gold Coast, GWS, Carlton, Adelaide, and St Kilda, trialed dual-ruck strategies.

Player Movements and Injuries

Pre-season saw numerous player movements and significant injury updates:

  • Adelaide: Mark Keane (broken leg) and Dan Curtin (dislocated kneecap) faced long-term absences. Izak Rankine was suspended for Round 1 and also recovering from a hamstring injury.
  • Brisbane: Sam Draper (foot stress fracture) was sidelined for 6-8 weeks, missing Round 1. Harris Andrews, Zac Bailey, Darcy Gardiner, and Hugh McCluggage sustained injuries or suspensions during Opening Round.
  • Carlton: Jesse Motlop (ACL) was out for the season. Adam Cerra (hamstring) was expected to miss the first month. Jacob Weitering recovered from a fractured rib.
  • Collingwood: Darcy Moore and Jeremy Howe faced calf injuries, making them doubtful for the season opener. Bobby Hill was on personal leave. Scott Pendlebury was managing an Achilles strain.
  • Essendon: Nic Martin (ACL) was out for the season. Zach Merrett stepped down as captain, with Andrew McGrath assuming the role, following a failed trade bid. Mason Redman sustained a knee injury.
  • Fremantle: Sean Darcy (calf) and Alex Pearce (calf awareness) were managing injuries. Mason Cox joined via the Supplemental Selection Period (SSP).
  • Geelong: Jeremy Cameron (quad) and Patrick Dangerfield (calf) were doubtful for Opening Round. Tyson Stengle was on personal leave.
  • Gold Coast: Jed Walter was suspended for Round 1, and Matt Rowell (broken finger) was out for several weeks. Christian Petracca made his club debut.
  • GWS: Tom Green (ACL) and Josh Kelly (hip) faced long-term absences. Clayton Oliver debuted for the club.
  • Hawthorn: Will Day (shoulder surgery) was sidelined for months. Jai Newcombe's suspension was downgraded, making him available for Round 1.
  • Melbourne: Max Gawn (fractured finger) played through injury. Luker Kentfield (MCL) was out for six weeks, and Jack Viney (Achilles) was sidelined until Round 8.
  • North Melbourne: Jackson Archer (ACL) was out for the season. George Wardlaw (hamstring) missed early weeks.
  • Port Adelaide: Ivan Soldo (ACL) was out for the season. Connor Rozee (hamstring) and Miles Bergman (ankle) were injured in Round 2.
  • Richmond: Tom Lynch (hamstring) and Toby Nankervis (hamstring) were injured in Round 2. Samson Ryan received a one-week ban in Round 4.
  • St Kilda: Max King (calf) was out for several weeks. Rowan Marshall (concussion) returned in Round 2.
  • Sydney: Errol Gulden (ankle) was cleared after a pre-season scare. Taylor Adams (Achilles) was managing injury. Max King (back) was out for 5 months.
  • West Coast: Noah Long sustained a knee injury in a pre-season match simulation. Harry Edwards (concussion) was sidelined.

"The pre-season period saw a significant churn of player availability, with critical long-term injuries impacting several key teams before the season officially began."

Early Season Matches (March 2026)

Opening Round Results (March 5-8)

  • Sydney Swans (20.12.132) defeated Carlton Blues (10.9.69) by 63 points at the SCG. Sydney dominated the third quarter with 12 goals. Charlie Curnow (3 goals) debuted for Sydney. Carlton's Adam Saad left with hamstring tightness.
  • Gold Coast Suns (19.11.125) defeated Geelong Cats (10.9.69) by 56 points at People First Stadium. Christian Petracca (3 goals, 34 disposals) debuted for Gold Coast. Ollie Dempsey (4 goals) led Geelong's scoring.
  • Greater Western Sydney (19.8.122) defeated Hawthorn (14.11.95) by 27 points at Engie Stadium. Jake Stringer (5 goals) led GWS, and Clayton Oliver (27 touches) debuted. Jack Gunston (4 goals) was Hawthorn's leading scorer.
  • Western Bulldogs (16.15.111) defeated Brisbane Lions (15.16.106) by 5 points at The Gabba. The Bulldogs overcame a 26-point deficit. Brisbane's Harris Andrews, Zac Bailey, and Darcy Gardiner received suspensions after the match, and Hugh McCluggage sustained a calf strain.

Round 1 Results (March 12-15)

  • Hawthorn (21.19.145) defeated Essendon (13.5.83) by 62 points at the MCG. Jack Gunston kicked 5 goals for Hawthorn. Zach Merrett (32 disposals) was Essendon's leading ball-winner.
  • Western Bulldogs (21.8.134) defeated Greater Western Sydney (7.11.53) by 81 points at Marvel Stadium. Marcus Bontempelli (3 goals) and Aaron Naughton (6 goals) led the Bulldogs. GWS player Harvey Thomas's contact with Matthew Kennedy was referred to the MRO.
  • Geelong (15.11.101) defeated Fremantle (13.13.91) by 10 points at GMHBA Stadium. Jeremy Cameron (3 goals) for Geelong. Fremantle's Jye Amiss kicked 4 goals. Jaeger O'Meara (hamstring) and Brennan Cox (calf) were sidelined for Fremantle.
  • Sydney Swans (15.10.100) defeated Brisbane Lions (9.12.66) by 34 points at the SCG. Sydney secured the victory, while Brisbane was notably without suspended key players.
  • Adelaide Crows (13.15.93) defeated Collingwood (11.13.79) by 14 points at the MCG, marking Adelaide's first win against Collingwood at the venue since 2014. Riley Thilthorpe kicked 3 goals for Adelaide. Collingwood's Scott Pendlebury was reviewed by the MRO for a collision with James Worrell.
  • North Melbourne (15.4.94) defeated Port Adelaide (12.13.85) by 9 points at Marvel Stadium. North Melbourne's Nick Larkey kicked 4 goals. Port Adelaide's Connor Rozee (hyperextended leg) and Mason Redman (knee) were injured.
  • Melbourne (18.12.120) defeated St Kilda (15.17.107) by 13 points at the MCG. Jacob van Rooyen kicked 6 goals for Melbourne. Max Hall (4 goals) led St Kilda.
  • Gold Coast Suns (20.11.131) defeated West Coast Eagles (10.12.72) by 59 points at People First Stadium. Ben King (5 goals) and Christian Petracca (4 goals) led Gold Coast. West Coast's Willem Duursma (2 goals) and Milan Murdock (2 goals) debuted.

Subsequent Rounds (March - April 2026)

Round 2 Results (March 27-29)

  • Hawthorn (14.15.99) defeated Sydney Swans (13.4.82) by 17 points. Jack Gunston kicked 4 goals for Hawthorn. Sydney was without Errol Gulden (shoulder surgery) and Isaac Heeney (hamstring). Hawthorn's Nick Watson alleged a bottle was thrown at him from the Sydney cheer squad.
  • Western Bulldogs (14.11.94) defeated Adelaide Crows (13.10.88) by 6 points at Adelaide Oval. Oskar Baker scored the game-winning goal for the Bulldogs. Adelaide's Callum Ah Chee sustained a hamstring injury. A clock malfunction in the fourth quarter caused confusion.
  • Gold Coast Suns (19.14.128) defeated Richmond (9.6.60) by 68 points. Ben King (7 goals) and Ethan Read (4 goals) contributed for Gold Coast. Christian Petracca (hamstring), Tom Lynch (hamstring), and Toby Nankervis (hamstring) all left the game with injuries.
  • St Kilda (11.12.78) defeated Greater Western Sydney (10.14.74) by 4 points at Engie Stadium. The match experienced a 50-minute lightning delay. St Kilda's Jack Sinclair (32 disposals) and Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera (27 disposals) were key performers.
  • Fremantle (17.16.118) defeated Melbourne (10.10.70) by 48 points at Optus Stadium. Josh Treacy (4 goals) led Fremantle's attack. Fremantle's Pat Voss engaged in on-field interactions, including a crying gesture toward Melbourne's Harrison Petty. Daniel Turner (hand injury) left the game for Melbourne.
  • Port Adelaide (20.13.133) defeated Essendon (10.10.70) by 63 points at Adelaide Oval. Port Adelaide's Zak Butters (36 disposals) and Aliir Aliir (19 marks) were prominent. Essendon's Mason Redman sustained a knee injury. Essendon players held a meeting to address performance, and coach Brad Scott publicly criticized the team for perceived selfishness.
  • West Coast Eagles (17.9.111) defeated North Melbourne (15.4.94) by 17 points at Optus Stadium, ending their 14-game losing streak. West Coast overcame a 30-point deficit in the second quarter. North Melbourne's Nick Larkey kicked 6 goals. Harry Edwards (West Coast) sustained a concussion.

Round 3 Results (March 27-29)

  • Collingwood (13.9.87) defeated Greater Western Sydney (7.12.54) by 33 points at Marvel Stadium. Debutant Oscar Steene kicked his first goal for Collingwood. Scott Pendlebury (Achilles tightness) and Darcy Moore (hamstring awareness) left the game injured for Collingwood.
  • Brisbane Lions (14.15.99) defeated St Kilda (13.9.87) by 12 points.
  • Fremantle (13.25.103) defeated Richmond (6.7.43) by 60 points at Optus Stadium. Josh Treacy (4 goals) led Fremantle. Richmond was without Tom Lynch and Toby Nankervis due to hamstring injuries.
  • North Melbourne (14.12.96) defeated Essendon (13.8.86) by 10 points at Marvel Stadium. North Melbourne scored the final five goals of the game. North Melbourne's Tristan Xerri was referred to the Tribunal for allegedly smearing blood on Essendon's Andrew McGrath.
  • West Coast Eagles (13.14.92) defeated Port Adelaide (13.12.90) by 2 points at Adelaide Oval. West Coast overcame a 29-point deficit. Jake Waterman (4 goals) was a key performer for West Coast. Port Adelaide's Esava Ratugolea sustained a knee injury, and West Coast's Elliot Yeo suffered a groin injury.
  • Melbourne (15.10.100) defeated Carlton (11.11.77) by 23 points at the MCG. Melbourne overcame a 43-point deficit. Bayley Fritsch (4 goals in the second half) and Max Gawn (250th game, 58 hitouts) were notable. Carlton's Zac Williams (ribs) and Harry Dean (hip) sustained injuries. Carlton faced criticism for a third consecutive second-half collapse.

Round 4 Results (April 3-5)

  • North Melbourne (14.12.96) defeated Carlton (13.8.86) by 10 points at Marvel Stadium. North Melbourne scored the final five goals, overcoming Carlton's 22-point three-quarter-time lead. Carlton's Jacob Weitering left the game with a concussion. Will Hayward (Carlton) received a one-match ban for striking George Wardlaw (North). Coach Michael Voss faced increased pressure due to Carlton's repeated late-game collapses.
  • Fremantle (11.12.78) defeated Adelaide Crows (11.10.76) by 2 points at Adelaide Oval. Jye Amiss (4 goals) led Fremantle. Adelaide made a strong comeback after trailing by 34 points in the third quarter.
  • Port Adelaide (13.12.90) defeated Richmond (6.12.48) by 42 points at the MCG. Port Adelaide's Jason Horne-Francis (2 goals) and Mitch Georgiades (2 goals) were key. Richmond's Samson Ryan received a one-week ban for an off-the-ball punch.
  • Sydney Swans (24.19.163) defeated West Coast Eagles (4.11.35) by 128 points at Optus Stadium. Isaac Heeney (4 goals) and Brodie Grundy (28 disposals, 33 hitouts) led Sydney. This was West Coast's fifth-heaviest defeat. West Coast's Harley Reid was targeted with a hard tag and received a 50-meter penalty.
  • Melbourne (16.13.109) defeated Gold Coast Suns (14.5.89) by 20 points at the MCG, ending Gold Coast's undefeated streak. Jake Melksham (4 goals) and Max Gawn (22 disposals, 32 hitouts) were key for Melbourne. Gold Coast coach Damien Hardwick critiqued his team's midfield performance.
  • Western Bulldogs (14.15.99) defeated Essendon (9.11.65) by 34 points at Marvel Stadium. Essendon recorded its 17th consecutive loss. Western Bulldogs' Tim English (right knee), Arty Jones (hamstring), and Ed Richards (knee) sustained injuries.

League-Wide Developments

Player Conduct and Tribunal Decisions

Several players faced Match Review Officer (MRO) scrutiny and Tribunal decisions:

  • Brisbane's Harris Andrews (3 weeks), Zac Bailey (1 week), and Darcy Gardiner (1 week) were suspended after Opening Round.
  • North Melbourne's Tristan Xerri was referred to the Tribunal for allegedly smearing blood on Essendon's Andrew McGrath.
  • Richmond's Samson Ryan received a one-week ban for an off-the-ball punch.
  • Carlton's Will Hayward received a one-match ban for striking North Melbourne's George Wardlaw.
  • Collingwood challenged a one-week suspension offered to Scott Pendlebury for a collision. Pendlebury's pursuit of the all-time V/AFL games record was delayed by his Round 4 absence.
  • Hawthorn's Nick Watson reported a bottle-throwing incident from the Sydney cheer squad.
  • West Coast's Harley Reid's on-field frustration and penalties drew attention.

Coaching Outlook and Club Strategies

  • Carlton: Coach Michael Voss faced increased scrutiny after repeated second-half collapses and lead losses. The club reaffirmed support but acknowledged disappointment.
  • Essendon: Coach Brad Scott noted a "selfish mentality" within the team and expressed optimism despite a record losing streak, emphasizing a "medium-to-long-term rebuild." The club is reportedly considering a significant list overhaul.
  • Gold Coast: Coach Damien Hardwick indicated his team was "spanked" in the midfield by Melbourne, identifying it as a "wake-up call."
  • Melbourne: Under new coach Steven King, the team displayed an attacking game style and noted improved belief and camaraderie.
  • Tasmania (19th AFL Club): Reportedly seeking veteran players to establish team culture, though their stadium construction has been delayed to 2031.

Injury Trends and Player Management

Data indicated a 5.1% increase in sprint efforts and a 3.7% rise in high-speed meters per team, which experts linked to a surge in hamstring injuries for multiple high-profile players. Clubs adapted to the five-player interchange bench, with some star players experiencing reduced time on ground, while veterans saw increased minutes.

Competitive Balance and Future Draft

Analysis identified a "significant gap" between 12 "Division 1" and 6 "Division 2" teams, with Division 1 teams winning all initial matchups against Division 2 teams by an average of 62 points. Concerns were raised about competitive imbalance and the potential for struggling teams to remain at the bottom, especially with impending draft rule changes expected to increase draft pick prices.

"A stark competitive imbalance has emerged early in the season, raising questions about the league's competitive fairness and the future of struggling clubs amidst evolving draft rules."

Concussion Lawsuit Update

The multimillion-dollar concussion class action against the AFL expanded, with eight additional former players joining the lawsuit, bringing the total to over 100 players and naming 10 more clubs as defendants. Plaintiffs allege permanent, life-altering injuries due to concussions resulting from negligence.