Joe Ryan, Twins Settle Arbitration with New Contract

Ryan Secures New Deal, Avoids Arbitration

The Minnesota Twins and pitcher Joe Ryan have reached an agreement on a new contract, successfully avoiding a potentially contentious arbitration hearing. This deal guarantees Ryan $6.2 million, addressing his second of three arbitration-eligible seasons.

Deal Specifics

The new contract includes a $6.1 million salary for the upcoming season, along with a $100,000 buyout for a $13 million mutual option in 2027. Last year, Ryan earned $3 million.

Arbitration Background and Resolution

Ryan was among 18 players who had not secured an agreement by the filing deadline earlier this month. Arbitration projections from MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz estimated Ryan's salary at $5.8 million. The Twins filed their figure at $5.85 million, while Ryan's camp filed at $6.35 million. The terms of this new agreement strategically fall between these two initial arbitration figures.

This contract allows the club to bypass potentially contentious arbitration hearings.

The Arbitration Process: "File and Trial" Exceptions

Many major league teams typically adopt a "file and trial" approach, which involves ceasing one-year contract negotiations after the arbitration filing deadline. This strategy is often used to strengthen the team's position heading into a potential hearing.

However, exceptions to this rule are frequently made. Agreements that extend beyond a single year or incorporate options, such as Joe Ryan's new deal, are common exceptions. Notably, deals that include options are not permitted as comparison points in subsequent arbitration hearings, further influencing their utility.

Implications for Ryan and the Twins

Future Control and Trade Value

The mutual option outlined in the contract primarily functions as an accounting mechanism. It's important to note that mutual options are rarely exercised by both parties. Regardless of the option's outcome, Ryan will remain under club control for the 2027 season.

Last summer, Ryan was a name mentioned in trade discussions, particularly during a period when the Twins were active in player transactions. While initial expectations leaned towards a potential winter trade, the team has since pivoted its strategy, now focusing on contending through 2026. Ryan continues to possess significant trade value, largely due to his modest salary and remaining years of club control. This factor could become a consideration again should the team's competitive standing shift in the future.

League-Wide Arbitration Landscape Settles

With this recent agreement, the Minnesota Twins' arbitration class for the current year is now fully settled. Across Major League Baseball, a maximum of 15 arbitration hearings are currently anticipated for the year, a reduction achieved following the recent settlements involving Ryan, Cade Cavalli, and Bryce Miller since the filing deadline.